Huntington Beach Lawsuit Challenges California’s SB 54 Sanctuary Policy and Its Impact on Local Law Enforcement

Violation notice on clipboard beside pen.

Huntington Beach challenges California’s sanctuary law, igniting a fierce legal battle over immigration enforcement and public safety.

At a Glance

  • Huntington Beach sues California over SB 54, the state’s sanctuary law
  • The lawsuit claims SB 54 violates the Constitution and impedes local law enforcement
  • Mayor Pat Burns cites rising crime rates as justification for the legal challenge
  • California Attorney General Rob Bonta vows to defend the sanctuary policy
  • The case reignites debate over federal vs. state authority in immigration enforcement

Huntington Beach Takes on California’s Sanctuary Law

The City of Huntington Beach has filed a lawsuit against the state of California, challenging the constitutionality of Senate Bill 54 (SB 54), also known as the California Values Act. This sanctuary law, enacted in 2017, limits cooperation between local law enforcement agencies and federal immigration authorities, particularly Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

The lawsuit, spearheaded by Huntington Beach Mayor Pat Burns and City Attorney Michael Gates, argues that SB 54 not only violates the U.S. Constitution but also poses a significant threat to public safety. The city is seeking declaratory and injunctive relief to invalidate the state law, which they claim hampers their ability to protect the community effectively.

Rising Crime Rates and Public Safety Concerns

Mayor Burns has been vocal about the perceived negative impacts of the sanctuary law on Huntington Beach. He argues that SB 54 obstructs local law enforcement’s ability to fully enforce the law and maintain community safety. The lawsuit cites examples from Orange County, where inmates with ICE detainers were released and subsequently rearrested for new crimes.

“We are fighting the Sanctuary State Law because it obstructs our ability to fully enforce the law and keep our community safe. When the stakes are currently so high, with reports of increases in human trafficking, increases in foreign gangs taking over apartment buildings in the U.S., killing, raping, and committing other violent crimes against our citizens, we need every possible resource available to fight crime, including federal resources.” – Huntington Beach Mayor Pat Burns

The city’s complaint includes references to high-profile crimes committed by illegal immigrants, which Burns and other officials argue could have been prevented if local law enforcement had been allowed to cooperate fully with federal immigration authorities.

Legal Grounds and Constitutional Challenges

Huntington Beach’s lawsuit rests on several legal arguments. The city contends that SB 54 violates the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, which establishes federal law as the supreme law of the land. Additionally, they argue that the law infringes upon the federal government’s exclusive authority over immigration matters under the Naturalization Clause.

“Huntington Beach will not sit idly by and allow the obstructionist Sanctuary State Law to put our 200,000 residents at risk of harm from those who seek to commit violent crimes on U.S. soil.” – Huntington Beach Mayor Pat Burns

The city also asserts its status as a charter city, which it claims grants it greater autonomy in municipal affairs, including law enforcement policies. This argument seeks to challenge the state’s authority to impose SB 54 on local jurisdictions.

State’s Defense and Previous Challenges

California Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office has vowed to defend SB 54 vigorously. The state successfully fought off a previous challenge to the law by the Trump administration, and Bonta’s office appears confident in its ability to do so again.

“The Attorney General is committed to protecting and ensuring the rights of California’s immigrant communities and upholding vital laws like SB 54. Our office successfully fought back against a challenge to SB 54 by the first Trump administration, and we are prepared to vigorously defend SB 54 again.” – a spokesperson for California Attorney General Rob Bonta

The lawsuit has reignited the debate over sanctuary policies in California, with opinions sharply divided. Some local governments have enhanced their sanctuary policies, while others, like Huntington Beach, are actively opposing them. This legal challenge may set a precedent for other municipalities considering similar actions against state-imposed sanctuary laws.

Sources:

  1. California Slapped With Lawsuit Over ‘Unconstitutional’ Sanctuary Law |
  2. Huntington Beach sues California over sanctuary state law
  3. California Slapped with Lawsuit Over ‘Unconstitutional’ Sanctuary Law

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR