Debate Over Biden’s Clemency Decisions Following Release of “Black Widow” Josephine Virginia Gray

Man speaking into a microphone at an event.

President Biden’s clemency decisions spark controversy as “Black Widow” Josephine Virginia Gray is released, challenging the administration’s promise of pardoning non-violent offenders.

At a Glance

  • Biden commuted sentences for nearly 1,500 people and pardoned 39 others in a single day
  • Josephine Virginia Gray, convicted of insurance fraud related to deaths of three partners, was among those released
  • Gray’s release contradicts White House claims of only freeing non-violent offenders
  • Biden’s clemency actions face criticism, including for pardoning his son Hunter Biden
  • Debate ensues over the scope and criteria of presidential pardons

Biden’s Historic Clemency Action Raises Eyebrows

President Joe Biden has made headlines with what the White House describes as the largest single-day act of clemency in modern presidential history. The President commuted the sentences of nearly 1,500 individuals and pardoned 39 others, a move that has ignited intense debate over the use of presidential pardoning power.

The individuals affected by Biden’s clemency action were reportedly serving long sentences that would be shorter under current laws, with many having been on home confinement since the COVID-19 pandemic began. The White House emphasized that most of the pardoned individuals had committed non-violent drug offenses in their youth and have since reintegrated into their communities.

The Controversial Case of Josephine Virginia Gray

Among those granted clemency was Josephine Virginia Gray, known as the “Black Widow,” whose release has become a focal point of criticism. Gray was convicted in 2002 for insurance fraud related to the deaths of two husbands and a boyfriend between 1974 and 1996. She collected $165,000 from insurance settlements and was charged with murder but ultimately convicted for insurance fraud under the “slayers rule.”

“It pisses me off, as you can imagine,” said James Trusty, a former federal prosecutor. “What in God’s name created the impetus to help her?”

Gray’s release appears to contradict the White House’s claim that Biden only released “non-violent” offenders, fueling concerns about the vetting process for clemency recipients. The case has reignited discussions about the criteria used in selecting individuals for pardons and commutations.

Broader Implications of Biden’s Clemency Decisions

Biden’s clemency actions extend beyond individual cases like Gray’s. The President has issued more commutations than any recent president at this point in their first term. He has also granted categorical pardons for marijuana possession and to LGBTQ+ individuals convicted due to their sexual orientation in the military.

“President Biden announced he is commuting the prison sentences for nearly 1,500 people and pardoning 39 others in what the White House described as the largest act of clemency in a single day in modern presidential history.” – NPR

However, these actions have not been without controversy. Biden faced significant backlash for issuing a blanket pardon to his son, Hunter Biden, for gun and tax charges outside the established pardon process. This move has led to accusations of nepotism and abuse of presidential powers.

The Ongoing Debate Over Presidential Pardons

The controversy surrounding Biden’s clemency decisions has reignited discussions about the scope and limitations of presidential pardoning power. The Presidential Pardon Power, outlined in Article II of the Constitution, allows the president to grant clemency for federal crimes. However, it does not extend to state-level offenses or impeached individuals.

“Under the fundamental rule that no one may be a judge in his own case, the president cannot pardon himself.” – Mary C Lawton

As the debate continues, clemency advocates argue that Biden could do more, particularly regarding the death penalty. Democratic lawmakers and activists have called for further action, urging the President to commute the sentences of those on death row. The White House has stated that Biden plans to continue reviewing clemency petitions to promote equal justice, public safety, and rehabilitation.

Sources:

  1. ‘Black Widow,’ Who Murdered 3 Ex-Lovers, Freed in Biden’s Historic Clemency Spree
  2. Biden commutes sentences for 1,500 people. Some say he could do a lot more
  3. Biden’s pardon reflects historic controversy surrounding US presidential power

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR